#AI ChatGPT – OpenAI: Could joint-ventures between students and universities better higher education?
I asked OpenAI:
"If Universities obtained part of their revenues from participating, in a small way, in the future earnings of their graduated students, let’s call it a joint-venture, could that align better the incentives for stimulating the achievement of a better higher education?"
OpenAI answered:
"The idea of universities obtaining a portion of their revenues from the future earnings of their graduates, creating a joint-venture-like arrangement, is an interesting concept that has been discussed and experimented with in some forms. This approach is often referred to as income share agreements (ISAs) or human capital contracts.
The main goal behind ISAs is to align the incentives of universities with the outcomes and success of their graduates. By tying a university's revenue to the future earnings of students, it theoretically creates a stronger incentive for the institution to provide high-quality education and support services that lead to better employment prospects and higher incomes for graduates.
Proponents of ISAs argue that this model can address some of the perceived shortcomings of traditional tuition-based systems. It can reduce the financial burden on students by offering more flexible repayment terms based on their actual earnings after graduation. Additionally, it may encourage universities to focus on skills and knowledge that are in high demand in the job market, potentially leading to better alignment between education and workforce needs.
However, there are several considerations and potential challenges associated with implementing ISAs. Some concerns include:
1. Risk and fairness: Determining a fair and appropriate income share percentage can be challenging. It should account for the risk taken by the university and balance it with the potential earnings of graduates. There is also a risk of burdening graduates with excessive repayment obligations if their income prospects are lower than anticipated.
2. Regulatory and legal complexities: Implementing ISAs involves navigating legal and regulatory frameworks related to financial agreements, privacy, and consumer protection. Developing a robust and transparent system to administer ISAs and handle disputes is crucial.
3. Measurement of success: Determining the success of an educational institution based solely on graduate earnings may oversimplify the multifaceted nature of education. It is important to consider other factors such as critical thinking skills, personal development, and societal contributions that are not directly tied to income.
4. Potential impact on access and equity: There is a concern that ISAs could disproportionately benefit high-income students who are more likely to earn higher salaries after graduation. Ensuring that ISAs are designed and implemented in a way that promotes equal access and does not exacerbate existing social inequalities is crucial.
Overall, the concept of tying university revenues to the future earnings of graduates through ISAs has both potential benefits and challenges. It is an evolving area with ongoing experimentation and research. Further exploration and careful consideration of the implications and implementation details are necessary to determine its viability and effectiveness in stimulating better higher education."
Posts
