My tax paradise (Nothing as powerful against tax havens as tax heavens)

My tax paradise is not, as some could think, a country where there are no taxes paid, but a country with a just, transparent and efficient tax system which, without weakening the citizen, allows for the fiscal revenue necessary for the government to undertake what the citizen considers it should undertake on their behalf… and nothing more. 

Currently such a fiscal paradise does not exist anywhere. In fact what dominates in the world is the existence of real Kafkaesque tax infernos. Countries capable of transforming themselves into tax paradises have all to gain. 

My tax paradise would be governed by the following two principles: 

1. Every person has the inalienable right to contribute to his country by the payment of taxes, no matter how poor he is. It is also unacceptable that citizens can be odiously divided by interested politicians and bureaucrats, in those paying and those not paying taxes.

2. The state must not receive any income other than those taxes paid directly by the citizens in their own name. It should be an inalienable right of citizens to have their governments work exclusively for them, without patrons or other interested parties, introducing confusion into such relation.

In this respect, in my tax paradise, any person who receives a single dollar in income, for any reason or from any source, pays taxes. The tax rate, progressive of course, could for example be between 10 and 49 percent. Never should the government be able to get hold of the largest portion of the income of any citizen, no matter how wealthy that citizen might be.

Companies would not be taxed at all, because their function is to create jobs and increase the taxable income of the citizens, something they can do much better without any distortions. Of course, companies would have to withhold and pay taxes on dividends paid to those who are not fiscally domiciled in the country.

All other revenue that may enter the state, such as the net oil revenues (Venezuela) and net import duties, should be distributed directly to citizens, in the extent that macroeconomic realities so permit, and will become part of their taxable income.

The tax revenues collected by the central state should be automatically distributed on a highly decentralized basis, which in our case (Venezuela) I visualize to be about 10 percent for the governorates and 40 percent to municipalities, 90 percent of these to be distributed based on population and 10 percent based on the territory. Municipalities may also collect their residential property taxes.

In cases of national emergency, and with the favorable vote of 80 percent of the Assembly, the National Assembly may also enact a tax on the value of financial assets up to a maximum of 1 percent per year, up to a maximum period of 3 years.

¿Could public services be privatized? Absolutely, but always allocated on the basis of minimizing user fees and not, as is usual, maximizing state revenues.

¿What about public debt? Not a penny more that 30 percent of GDP, and only long term debt.

I appreciate any suggestions you may have to help make even more paradisaical my tax paradise. 

Translated from Op-ed in El Universal

PS. Phrased in other words: Corporate taxes only dilute citizen's tax representation or... clearer yet... the corporations have hijacked the citizen's tax representation... to the delight of politicians.

PS. In order for the government to timely collect taxes on what derives from corporate profits, these profits, as shown on financial statements, should yearly be passed through to the shareholders, and the corporations, in order to assist the shareholders in the payment of those taxes, decree and pay some dividends.

PS. And of course, VAT and similar, beside being regressive do not give real representation, as there is not an identified citizen behind its payment.

PS. April 2016 "Panama Papers" Don't let redistribution agitation profiteers raise your expectations.

PS. Public borrowing capacity (or money printing seigniorage) is a valuable strategic asset that should not lightly be consumed or squandered.

Flashback: April 3, 1998 The taxes we have to pay! Daily Journal Please read it.

PS. Oh, how I dislike redistribution profiteers... let's diminish their franchise value with a Universal Basic Income

Not much added value to the value added tax on Margarita Island

If there is anything that has to do with economics that has been proven with absolute clarity over the last few decades is the unsurpassable capacity of the Venezuelan State to misspend its resources. 

In this sense, an recipe for getting ourselves out of this inherited economic disaster that begins with the transfer of additional resources to the government is utterly incomprehensible to me, and I am a fierce enemy of all new taxation, even more so when we are talking about the Value Added Tax (IVA) that does not provide even the slightest redistribution of income.

However, in the case of the Island of Margarita, I refuse to spend much of my energy in protesting the recently decreed VAT. My reasons? As the say in local argot, what’s one more stripe for a tiger?

In Venezuela today, tourism is the only sector that promises the potential of creating so many externally competitive and productive jobs. The Dominican Republic’s income from tourism during last year was in the neighborhood of US$ 2.5 billion. There is no question that today we should be rallying the entire country around a National Plan for Tourism, centered principally in Margarita.

But no! In September of last year, instead of investing in a submarine cable to Margarita from the mainland so as to be able to supply the island with cheap energy (a public service of utmost importance to tourism), the latter divested in tourism when it blithely sent the US$ 60 million obtained from the privatization of its power company to the National Treasury. Margarita’s hotels often spend more for power than they do in covering its payroll.

A real plan to promote tourism on the island would focus everyone on finding solutions for getting water to the island’s population and hotels cheaply and securely. This could, for example, be done either by installing a new pipeline under the sea from the mainland financed by multilateral entities or by offering to supply free or cheap gas which would permit the fueling of desalination plants that would not be ruinously expensive. Today, all we see are plans to install gas lines so as to be able to sell gas to the island at international prices.

Anyone that had a real interest in promoting tourism on Margarita would not allow the Bolivar to overvalue to the point that the only tourism promoted is the international tourism of Venezuelans.

Anyone that had a real interest in promoting tourism on Margarita would have offered fuel at marginal cost to all international flights that come from more that 1,000 kilometers away, that carry 100 tourists that will stay for over one week. In Europe, for every 100 units paid for gasoline by the consumer, only 10 goes to the producer of the same. I am sure that each barrel “given as a gift to tourism” would be economically more beneficial to the country than its direct sale.

More investment in Margarita would create more jobs. Instead, mediocre advisors recommend the application of the VAT for Margarita in the name of anti-national national solidarity and based on minor issues that only promote equality downwards. Even some representatives of the private sector applaud the application of another tax.

But all is not lost. On this marvelous island, where the ingenuity and genes of its native and assimilated population are put to work full time to confront all this adversity with spunk and elan, new promotional strategies are being designed and produced on a daily basis.

We are all aware of the fiscal pressures imposed on the European tourist at home. A new attraction is now being developed in Margarita; a new variant of adventure tourism called Fiscal Tourism.

Today, thanks to the VAT, Margarita can offer the European Tourist the tropical and liberating experience of being able to participate in tax evasion. Very soon, merchants on Margarita will offer Evasion Receipts, which will most surely be souvenirs, competing directly with any of the dried and lacquered fish sold at any souvenir shop in the Caribbean. 

Local groups are studying the possibility of raffling a citation by the SENIAT among every 5,000 tourists. It must be exciting for any German from Stuttgart to be able to frame and hang this citation from the tax authorities. This is much better than trophies such as the head of an African antelope no matter how wide its horns may be.

For Heaven’s sake, let us create some added value on the island before we think of taxing it!

http://ourcaribbean.blogspot.com/1999/05/not-much-added-value-to-tax-on.html

If I were president (II)

In yesterday’s installment I mentioned the fact that the first thing I must receive in order to responsibly comply with my presidential obligations are certain special powers. Supposing I actually received these powers, I then began to list some of the concrete measures as an example of what I would do during the first 100 days of my term in some specific areas of concern. Here are some more.

Education: A single, all encompassing data base must be put together, identifying each and every active teacher on a school-by-school basis. These teachers will immediately receive an increase in pay and an additional fixed percentage of the payroll amount will be awarded each school to cover administrative expenses. Evidence of false information will result in the immediate suspension (for lying, aiding or abetting) of all the teachers of that particular school. All others that are unduly receiving pay without working from the Ministry of Education will be awarded eternal vacations without pay.

Reduction of public spending: In order to rationalize public spending, as similar strategy as the one above will be implemented. All personnel that are to be dismissed will be paid the equivalent of three month’s salary and all other severance payments will be paid in the form of negotiable Public Sector Restoion Bonds (PSRB). The value of these bonds will increase in the measure that restoration of the public sector is successful.

Infrastructure: All savings from the restructuring process will be invested, after covering fiscal deficits over 3% of GNP, in infrastructure projects, such as energy and water for Margarita and Zulia and a truly nationwide railway system.

Housing: The Central Bank must immediately make available through the private banking system, a credit facility to the tune of US$ 2 billion aimed at issuing long term loans in US$ and fixed rates for acquisition of housing.

Foreign investment: Foreign capital investments will be regulated in order to minimize damage caused by short term capital flight (i.e., the Mexico syndrome). Other countries in Latin America have such regulations in place.

Economic diversification: The oil sector does not create employment. Venezuela’s commercial policies must be renegotiated to achieve the equilibrium of our trade balance in terms of employment generation and not balance in monetary terms as it stands now. An annual budget will be allotted to allow for the protection of certain sectors of the economy, specifically agriculture. Cover under this scheme will be allocated to those sectors within agriculture that we can be competitive in without excessive costs (i.e. rice rather than apples).

Petroleum/Petrochemicals: PDVSA will continue to manage the development of our petroleum industry. However, a special Office of the Petroleum Ombudsman (OPO) will be created. This will allow the common citizen to get closer and to increase his knowledge and control of what is the country’s principal asset. The members of this office will be elected at random from among a list of candidates that have been carefully screened, have complied with some basic requirements and have been presented as such by the Venezuelan people. The Office will be initially asked to analyze why the industry is spending its precious resources in rebuilding a slew of gas stations. In the same sense, I would like to insure that our petrochemical industry is not just reopening Sidor’s covered grave with its new investments.

Taxes/Duties: There will be no more value added tax (VAT) as long as the country continues to perceive significant income from oil. Customs at our ports will be handed over to the private sector management. This will ensure that income that should reach government accounts does not continue to feed unscrupulous individual pockets.

Superfluous functions: Until the State begins to perfectly comply with its responsibilities in fundamental areas such as education, health and security, all other superfluous functions will be suspended. For example: if the local stock market really needs a regulatory entity such as the National Security and Exchange Commission, the market must cover the costs incurred. Today, it is preferable to stamp each issue with the words “Beware – Not Regulated” than to create the false illusion that some control is imposed, and in some instances, actually abet fraud through simple omission.

Day 100 – Evaluation: If my team and I are not able to successfully implement our government’s plans, we must resign and convene new elections. Remember, I have initially made a promise to resign without pension and without a seat as Senator for life in order to avoid a) further degeneration of the stature of the office of the President and b) wasting another four years and nine months of this poor country’s destiny.