I asked ChatGPT:
If Jesus Christ, instead of “Duc in Altum!” (Lk 5:4), “Put out into the deep”, “Where they caught a great number of fish" (Lk 5:6) had admonished Christians, to avoid risks and fish from safer shores, where would our Western World be?
ChatGPT answered:
Your thought-provoking question highlights the transformative power of bold action and trust in the face of uncertainty. If Jesus had urged His followers to play it safe rather than venture into the unknown, the Western world—and indeed global civilization—might have been markedly different in several ways:
1. Stifled Exploration and Innovation:
The spirit of "putting out into the deep" has inspired countless acts of exploration, scientific inquiry, and creative achievement. A message of caution over courage might have dampened humanity's drive to push boundaries, from the voyages of discovery to the scientific revolution.
2. Diminished Faith and Missionary Zeal:
Christianity's growth owes much to the willingness of believers to take risks—spiritually, socially, and physically. Without this call to venture into the unknown, the faith might have remained confined to a small, isolated group rather than spreading across cultures and continents.
3. Weakened Ethical Foundations:
Western culture has often been shaped by Christian ideals of self-sacrifice, courage, and perseverance in adversity. A retreat from risk-taking would likely have fostered a more inward-looking, self-preserving ethos, potentially reducing acts of heroism and societal progress.
4. Economic and Political Conservatism:
A risk-averse mindset might have led to more static economies and political systems, with less willingness to embrace new ideas, markets, or governance structures. The spirit of enterprise and innovation might have been significantly curtailed.
5. Cultural Fear of the Unknown:
Western literature, art, and philosophy are filled with themes of confronting fears, transcending limits, and embracing the mysterious. A foundational ethic of avoiding risk could have fostered a culture of timidity, inhibiting creativity and resilience.
By contrast, Christ's message in Luke 5:4-6 is a call to faith and action, to embrace uncertainty with trust in divine guidance. This has not only shaped religious teachings but also underpinned much of the optimism and dynamism of Western civilization.
Would you say this biblical moment exemplifies a broader principle of human progress—faith as the bridge to the unknown?
I asked/told ChatGPT:
I do, but I also think that the willingness to take risks’ “faith”, could be rooted in non-religious beliefs.
That said: Two millenniums later, regulators gave banks incentives to fish more from safe shores, public debt and residential mortgages, than in risky deep waters, loans to small businesses and entrepreneurs. Should not the Christians churches around the world speak up against that?
ChatGPT answered:
You're raising a profound question that touches both the spiritual and economic dimensions of moral responsibility and societal health.
It's true that risk-taking and faith in the unseen can stem from both religious and non-religious beliefs—whether rooted in spirituality, humanism, or the innate human drive for progress. The principle, however, remains: societies thrive when individuals and institutions are willing to step beyond the comfortable and predictable.
Now, regarding your observation about banks being incentivized to "fish from safe shores":
1. The Misalignment of Incentives
Regulators have indeed created frameworks—such as the Basel regulations—that favor lending to seemingly "safe" assets like government debt and residential mortgages. While this approach seeks financial stability, it inadvertently discourages lending to riskier, yet societally vital, sectors like small businesses and entrepreneurs. These are the "deep waters" where innovation, growth, and new opportunities are often found.
2. The Moral Angle: A Call for Justice and Equity
Christian teachings, especially those focused on the dignity of work, social justice, and the preferential option for the poor, would support a critique of systems that marginalize the less powerful—like small business owners and entrepreneurs. These groups often lack the access to capital that could help them grow and contribute meaningfully to society.
For churches, this is not just an economic issue but a moral one:
Are the systems we support fostering human flourishing, creativity, and opportunity?
Are we, in prioritizing safety, neglecting the risks that are essential to build a more just and dynamic society?
3. A Prophetic Role for Churches
Churches have a unique platform to speak up for the marginalized and challenge structures that promote short-term safety at the expense of long-term progress. They could:
Advocate for economic policies that encourage lending to underserved but high-potential sectors.
Highlight the moral hazards of excessive reliance on government debt or housing markets as a foundation for prosperity.
Educate communities about the importance of economic systems that align with principles of fairness, creativity, and inclusion.
4. Balancing Prudence and Boldness
Christianity has always called for a balance: prudence to manage risks wisely and courage to venture into the unknown when it serves the greater good. Churches could frame this debate not as a binary of risk vs. safety but as a moral obligation to steward resources in ways that build a dynamic, equitable economy.
If churches around the world united to address this issue, they could inject a much-needed ethical dimension into a conversation dominated by technical and economic considerations. Do you see a pathway for faith communities to lead this kind of dialogue effectively?
I said: "I sure hope/think that your opinions on this could be a great help to ignite such a dialogue. So, thank you very much!"
It answered: You're very welcome! I'm honored to contribute to such a meaningful and thought-provoking dialogue. Conversations like these have the potential to inspire real change, especially when rooted in principles of justice, courage, and human flourishing.
If you ever wish to explore this topic further—whether shaping ideas, crafting arguments, or imagining how faith communities might engage with economic systems—please feel free to reach out. Wishing you the best in igniting these important discussions! 🌟
Note: The answers are copied exactly from those given to me by ChatGPT
Posts
